It depends on your priorities. Newton Centre and Chestnut Hill command the highest prices and offer walkability and prestige. West Newton and Newtonville provide strong value with commuter rail access and active village centers. Waban and Newton Highlands attract families looking for quieter, residential settings. Newton Upper Falls and Nonantum offer the most accessible entry points, particularly for condos. Most buyers narrow their search to two or three villages based on budget, commute, and lifestyle.